1. Guest, did you know that we are counting on you to become a actively participating member of our Club and Forum? Click here to see how:

Dismiss Notice
Welcome To ShrimpNFishFLorida
Dismiss Notice
In order to view Reports and Posts in the (R) restricted access threads of this forum you must sign up as a member
Dismiss Notice
Guest After signup you will need to make an Introduction Post. Thanks

Live Vs Deadbait

Discussion in 'Fishing Chatter = anything to do with fishing' started by adallas, Aug 30, 2020.


  1. adallas

    adallas Blackbeard
    Fishing Chatter

    I mostly fish dead bait for a couple of reasons.
    • I can’t throw a big cast net worth a crap
    • Mostly catch grunts and want smaller baits for the types of fish that you can keep not the mythical red snapper.
    • Can’t find many sardines or cigar minnows
    Do you have just as good luck with mangroves with dead bait?

    what do you use.
     
    Just4Fun and Nautical Gator like this.
  2. Rich M

    Rich M Scallywag

    Grunt plugs are No. 1 for grovers.

    Live Shrimp works too.
     
    Just4Fun likes this.
  3. Nautical Gator

    Nautical Gator Forum Captain, Moderator, Peacekeeper Staff Member

    offshore just chunk cut up the grunts and drop on to the bottom. mangos seem to like them.
     
    Just4Fun likes this.
  4. adallas

    adallas Blackbeard
    Fishing Chatter

    Yeah I need to do a better job of finding Mangroves. I’ve caught a couple at East 11. Maybe because I mostly drift. Last time I anchored on site 7 we were able to get a few cigar minnows and caught a Cubera or a do snapper. Thought it was strange for central Florida
     
  5. mkyota1

    mkyota1 Sailing Master

    Most times that I have tried smaller live bait it always ends up eaten by red snapper. Like others have said grunt chunks are my bait of choice.
     
    Just4Fun likes this.
  6. rich dude

    rich dude Greenhorn

    Live shrimp. If they are stealing the bait I hook up some sand fleas for mangos
     
    Just4Fun likes this.
  7. I've caught mangroves in the Halifax River and in the surf at Ormond lately (to my surprise). I take live shrimp but never keep them alive. I put them in a ziplock without any water (or they can get water-logged on long day) and keep them on ice in my cooler. They stay looking alive all day that way, and I catch everything that likes live shrimp using those fresh dead, including mangrove snapper. I've also caught them while fishing with sand fleas, but they seem to hit the shrimp more readily.
     
    Just4Fun and mak like this.
  8. Tarpun

    Tarpun Pirate

    Offshore gruntheads or steaks for mangroves. Just legal Vermillion or kingfish head for grouper. In the river cut mullet for snapper.
     
    Just4Fun and Rich M like this.
  9. garbageman_ct

    garbageman_ct Pirate

    Fresh dead will keep the catfish off your line inshore or at least have a better chance
     
  10. thegoschman

    thegoschman Junior Member

    Anyone have any luck using salted bait?? Shrimp etc?? I spend a ton of money on the shrimp and decided to start salting them. Other than having them stay on the hook longer, the performance is no different to live ones as far as I can see.
     
  11. mak

    mak Moderator on Deck Staff Member

    Have been meaning to try it for next time I head to the pier. I’ve heard nothing but good things from it. http://www.shrimpnfishflorida.com/forums/threads/brining-surf-baits.58/
     
  12. Rich M

    Rich M Scallywag

    I go back and forth between live or frozen shrimp.

    Depends on the fish and what's in season. No way I'm buying $12/doz jumbo baits to catch fish that will get thrown back in.
     
  13. Joseph Underwood

    Joseph Underwood Powder Monkey

    Use to us bass assassins all the time in mangroves. Snook and gator troat mostly
     
  14. GARY15010

    GARY15010 Greenhorn

    Live Shrimp or soft crabs when available
     

Share This Page